79531-2025 - Result
Germany – Gas-distribution network – Cold Connection of Super-FRS BB to Branch G
OJ S 25/2025 05/02/2025
Contract or concession award notice – standard regime
Supplies
1. Buyer
1.1.
Buyer
Official name: FAIR - Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research in Europe GmbH
Email: proekf33@gsi.de
Legal type of the buyer: Public undertaking, controlled by a central government authority
Activity of the contracting authority: Education
2. Procedure
2.1.
Procedure
Title: Cold Connection of Super-FRS BB to Branch G
Description: For the connection of the Branch Box BB of the Super-FRS accelerator system at FAIR to the local experimentals branch G for the R3B and GLAD experiments about ninety meters of cryogenic and warm gas helium transfer lines have to be designed, produced and installed at the FAIR site.
Procedure identifier: fbea0b42-ebb2-4cdb-a15b-c9cff0a474bc
Internal identifier: 33/2600018775FAIR
Type of procedure: Negotiated with prior publication of a call for competition / competitive with negotiation
The procedure is accelerated: no
2.1.1.
Purpose
Main nature of the contract: Supplies
Main classification (cpv): 44161110 Gas-distribution network
Additional classification (cpv): 42500000 Cooling and ventilation equipment, 45231112 Installation of pipe system
2.1.2.
Place of performance
Postal address: FAIR - Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research in Europe GmbH Planckstr. 1 
Town: Darmstadt
Postcode: 64291
Country subdivision (NUTS): Darmstadt, Kreisfreie Stadt (DE711)
Country: Germany
2.1.4.
General information
Additional information: Bekanntmachungs-ID: CXS0YYEYT6NUDTD4 The only form of submission of participation applications accepted by Awarding Authority is in writing, electronically Note: In Writing, Electronically Participation applications shall be submitted electronically within the deadline via the German awarding platform DTVP. URL: http://www.dtvp.de/Center/ The forms and other documents to be completed, provided by FAIR, may be - either completed on the online tendering tool under the section "Documents to Be Completed" or - created and compiled separately by Candidate together with the other components of the participation application or tender (concepts or explanations etc.), then uploaded under the heading "Own Documents". However, Candidates should not fill in the forms online and upload them again separately, as this can result in transmission errors and increases the workload on both sides. In order to comply with the text form (in writing) according to § 126b BGB [transl.: German Civil Code] when submitting participation applications, Candidates must provide the following information: - In the case of natural persons, the full name (first name and surname) must be given (name of the declaring person in the participation application form). - In the case of legal entities and commercial companies and corporations, the name of the company and its legal form must be stated. In addition, the full name of the employee who is submitting the participation application on behalf of the company (name of the declaring person in the participation application form) must be stated. The insertion of a company logo is not sufficient. - In the case of Bidding Consortia, the declaring person according to § 126b BGB shall be the employee of the leading member who submits the participation application on behalf of the Bidding Consortium; besides, the form "Bidding Consortium Declaration" must be submitted. It should be noted that in the case of electronic submission, the text form according to § 126b BGB is only observed if the participation applications are transmitted in encrypted form via the awarding platform (cf. information on eVergabe). Submitting the participation application via email is not sufficient. In the case of incorrect/ incomplete information that violates the aforementioned formal requirements, participation applications will be excluded unless Candidate cannot be held responsible (§ 57 para. 1 nr. 1, para. 3 VgV). ----------------------- Note: Weighting (Best possible rating is 10 and worst possible rating is 0) 40 % price 60 % performance criteria - Performance criteria: 60% are scaled to 100% 1. Quality of the Offer & Presentation = 25 % 2. Quality Assurance, Communication and Documentation = 25 % 3. Schedule = 25 % 4. = Technical Design & Quality 25 % ----------------------- Note: Communication with Candidates Communication with Candidates takes place via the DTVP's tender platform. Questions must be sent to FAIR via DTVP and will are answered via DTVP. Questions posed orally or by telephone regarding the documents or the contractual object will not be answered; answers given orally or by telephone are not binding. ------------------------ Note: Electronic Invoicing "The XInvoicing format is accepted with additional transmission of the invoice as a -pdf-."
Legal basis: 
Directive 2014/24/EU
vgv -
5. Lot
5.1.
Lot: LOT-0001
Title: Cold Connection of Super-FRS BB to Branch G
Description: For the connection of the Branch Box BB of the Super-FRS accelerator system at FAIR to the local experimentals branch G for the R3B and GLAD experiments about ninety meters of cryogenic and warm gas helium transfer lines have to be designed, produced and installed at the FAIR site. The four process headers for the 4 and 50 K supply and return are combined inside a DN 400 vacuum insulated main transfer line. This main line is partly accompanied a DN200 vacuum insulated single process line, called multi-purpose return line, by a DN 80 non-insulated 300 K helium warm gas supply line, and a DN 80 non-insulated current lead return line. These four parallel lines are called transfer line bundle (TLB).
Internal identifier: 33/2600018775FAIR
5.1.1.
Purpose
Main nature of the contract: Supplies
Main classification (cpv): 44161110 Gas-distribution network
Additional classification (cpv): 42500000 Cooling and ventilation equipment, 45231112 Installation of pipe system
5.1.2.
Place of performance
Postal address: FAIR - Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research in Europe GmbH Planckstr. 1 
Town: Darmstadt
Postcode: 64291
Country subdivision (NUTS): Darmstadt, Kreisfreie Stadt (DE711)
Country: Germany
5.1.4.
Renewal
Maximum renewals: 0
5.1.6.
General information
Procurement Project not financed with EU Funds.
The procurement is covered by the Government Procurement Agreement (GPA): yes
Additional information: Geignet für kleine und mittlere Unternehmen (KMU) = ja!
5.1.7.
Strategic procurement
Aim of strategic procurement: No strategic procurement
5.1.10.
Award criteria
Criterion: 
Type: Price
Name: Price
Category of award weight criterion: Weight (percentage, exact)
Award criterion number: 40
Criterion: 
Type: Quality
Name: Technical Design & Quality
Description: It is particularly important for the client that the offered solution fully meets the specification and that it is explained how the specified parameters will be achieved. It is also rated positively if the solution offers technical advantages over the specification. The main challenges were recognized and productive solutions were presented.
Category of award weight criterion: Weight (percentage, exact)
Award criterion number: 15
Criterion: 
Type: Quality
Name: Schedule
Description: It is particularly important for the client that the bidder provides a schedule for development, production, delivery, installation and test, that is comprehensible to the client and fits into the overall schedule of the FAIR project. The design phase must be included in the project planning with an appropriate time period to allow sufficient communication and involvement. A binding and comprehensible promise of compliance with the delivery schedule is evaluated positive = evaluation "Good". A shorter delivery schedule is evaluated positive = evaluation "Very Good". A longer deliverry schedule is evaluated negative = evaluation "Satisfactory".
Category of award weight criterion: Weight (percentage, exact)
Award criterion number: 15
Criterion: 
Type: Quality
Name: Schedule
Description: It is particularly important for the client that the bidder provides a schedule for development, production, delivery, installation and test, that is comprehensible to the client and fits into the overall schedule of the FAIR project. The design phase must be included in the project planning with an appropriate time period to allow sufficient communication and involvement. A binding and comprehensible promise of compliance with the delivery schedule is evaluated positive = evaluation "Good". A shorter delivery schedule is evaluated positive = evaluation "Very Good". A longer deliverry schedule is evaluated negative = evaluation "Satisfactory".
Category of award threshold criterion: Minimum score
Award criterion number: 10
Criterion: 
Type: Quality
Name: Quality of the Offer & Presentation
Description: It is particularly important for the client that it is recognizable that the contractor has understood the problem and that queries are answered competently. The solution approaches are presented and shown to be effective. A high level of detail in the presented solutions will be rated positively. The tender documents must allow conclusions to be drawn about compliance with the specification.
Category of award weight criterion: Weight (percentage, exact)
Award criterion number: 15
Criterion: 
Type: Quality
Name: Quality Assurance, Communication and Documentation
Description: It is particularly important for the client that the bidder pursues a coherent communication concept that ensures that the progress of the project can be managed effectively and efficiently and that the client is involved in the sub-processes (e.g. regular coordination meetings, video conferences, reports, well-defined group of participants). Furthermore, the bidder should present a concept for internal quality assurance (e.g. incoming goods inspection, standards applied, etc.). Compliance with the GSI standards must be evident from the documentation.
Category of award weight criterion: Weight (percentage, exact)
Award criterion number: 15
5.1.15.
Techniques
Framework agreement: 
No framework agreement
Information about the dynamic purchasing system: 
No dynamic purchase system
5.1.16.
Further information, mediation and review
Review organisation: Vergabekammer des Bundes
Information about review deadlines: The competent investigating authority is as follows Vergabekammer des Bundes Villemombler Str. 76 D-53123 Bonn, Germany Tel.: 0228 9499-0 Fax: 0228 9499-163 Email: vk@bundeskartellamt.bund.de Web: http://www.bundeskartellamt.de/SharedDocs/Kontaktdaten/DE/Vergabekammern.html The applicant is requested to clearly identify those parts of the request to participate (and any subsequent bid) containing company/business secrets. If this does not happen, the public procurement tribunal will assume consent to inspect the documents as required in the case of carrying out a review procedure (Section 165 (3) Act against Restraints of Competition (Competition Act - GWB)). As the awarding authority, FAIR is required to provide the public procurement tribunal with immediate access to the files when a review procedure is initiated (Section 163 (2) sentence 3 GWB). Applicants/bidders have the right to demand that the Contracting authority comply with the provisions on the award procedure protecting bidders (Section 97 (6) GWB). Applicants/bidders with an interest in the public contract who believe their rights have been violated by non-compliance with the provisions governing the awarding of public contracts, must raise an objection about the violation to FAIR within ten calendar days (Section 160 (3) sentence 1 no. 1 GWB). Violations known from the tender notice or tender documents must be claimed vis-a-vis FAIR before the time limit given for submission of applications (offers) (Section 160 (3) 1 No. 2 - 3 GWB). If FAIR informs the applicant/bidder that it is unwilling to redress the objection, an application for review may then be filed with the public procurement tribunal above within 15 days of receipt of the notification (Section 160 (3) sentence 1 no. 4 GWB). Bidders whose bids are not to be considered for the award of the contract will be notified before the awarding of the contract pursuant to Section 134 GWB. A contract may only be concluded 15 calendar days after FAIR has sent out this information. This period is ten calendar days when transmission is by fax or email. The period commences on the day following the dispatch of the information by FAIR. After this time period has expired, an award is possible even if a time limit pursuant to Section 160 (3) GWB has yet to expire. Therefore, in order to prevent an award, a request for review needs to have been served upon FAIR by the public procurement tribunal before the expiry of the time limit under Section 134 GWB. Pursuant to Section 135 (1) and (2) GWB, the invalidity of an award can only be established if it has been asserted in the review procedure within 30 calendar days from the date on which there was notification on the conclusion of the agreement, though no later than six months after the agreement was concluded. If the Contracting authority published the tender notice in the Official Journal of the European Union, the time limit for claiming ineffectiveness shall expire 30 calendar days after the publication of the tender notice in the Official Journal of the European Union.
Organisation providing additional information about the procurement procedure: FAIR - Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research in Europe GmbH
Organisation providing more information on the review procedures: Vergabekammer des Bundes
TED eSender: Datenservice Öffentlicher Einkauf (in Verantwortung des Beschaffungsamts des BMI)
6. Results
Value of all contracts awarded in this notice: 886 806,00 EUR
6.1.
Result lot identifier: LOT-0001
Winner selection status: At least one winner was chosen.
6.1.2.
Information about winners
Winner: 
Leader of tendering party: Cryoworld
Tender: 
Identifier of lot or group of lots: LOT-0001
Value of the tender: 886 806,00 EUR
The tender is a variant: no
Subcontracting: No
Contract information: 
Identifier of the contract: 1
Title: Cryoworld, 1771RW Wieringerwerf
Date of the conclusion of the contract: 20/01/2025
6.1.4.
Statistical information
Received tenders or requests to participate: 
Type of received submissions: Tenders
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 3
Type of received submissions: Tenders submitted electronically
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 3
Type of received submissions: Requests to participate
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 4
Type of received submissions: Tenders from tenderers registered in other European Economic Area countries than the country of the buyer
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 2
Type of received submissions: Tenders from tenders registered in countries outside of the European Economic Area
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 1
Type of received submissions: Tenders verified and inadmissible
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 0
Type of received submissions: Tenders verified and inadmissible because of an abnormally low price or cost
Number of tenders or requests to participate received: 0
Range of tenders: 
Value of the lowest admissible tender: 886 806,00 EUR
Value of the highest admissible tender: 1 113 504,00 EUR
8. Organisations
8.1.
ORG-0001
Official name: FAIR - Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research in Europe GmbH
Registration number: 29ce5e4e-444e-4794-9f0a-3fd388dffda0
Postal address: Planckstr. 1
Town: Darmstadt
Postcode: 64291
Country subdivision (NUTS): Darmstadt, Kreisfreie Stadt (DE711)
Country: Germany
Email: proekf33@gsi.de
Telephone: 0049 6159 71 1987
Roles of this organisation: 
Buyer
Organisation providing additional information about the procurement procedure
8.1.
ORG-0002
Official name: Vergabekammer des Bundes
Registration number: 976dfade-ec8d-4f9b-a116-71d7c29146c4
Postal address: Villemomblerstr. 76
Town: Bonn
Postcode: 53123
Country subdivision (NUTS): Bonn, Kreisfreie Stadt (DEA22)
Country: Germany
Contact point: Vergabekammer des Bundes
Email: vk@bundeskartellamt.bund.de
Telephone: +49 22894990
Roles of this organisation: 
Organisation providing more information on the review procedures
8.1.
ORG-0003
Official name: Vergabekammer des Bundes
Registration number: 1e0aa163-32b6-441f-a9fc-01c1f5734b6b
Postal address: Villemomblerstr. 76
Town: Bonn
Postcode: 53123
Country subdivision (NUTS): Bonn, Kreisfreie Stadt (DEA22)
Country: Germany
Email: vk@bundeskartellamt.bund.de
Telephone: +49 22894990
Roles of this organisation: 
Review organisation
8.1.
ORG-0004
Official name: Cryoworld
Size of the economic operator: Small
Registration number: cdf24539-9219-4421-84fc-742ab6444f0e
Postal address: Havenweg 11C
Town: Wieringerwerf
Postcode: 1771RW
Country subdivision (NUTS): Kop van Noord-Holland (NL321)
Country: Netherlands
Email: a.smit@cryoworld.com
Telephone: +31 228 743930
Roles of this organisation: 
Tenderer
Leader of tendering party
Beneficial owner: 
Nationality of the owner: Netherlands
Winner of these lots: LOT-0001
8.1.
ORG-0005
Official name: Datenservice Öffentlicher Einkauf (in Verantwortung des Beschaffungsamts des BMI)
Registration number: 0204:994-DOEVD-83
Town: Bonn
Postcode: 53119
Country subdivision (NUTS): Bonn, Kreisfreie Stadt (DEA22)
Country: Germany
Email: noreply.esender_hub@bescha.bund.de
Telephone: +49228996100
Roles of this organisation: 
TED eSender
Notice information
Notice identifier/version: 49ba7746-4289-43d5-b53b-e5316d42aec6  -  01
Form type: Result
Notice type: Contract or concession award notice – standard regime
Notice subtype: 29
Notice dispatch date: 04/02/2025 11:30:11 (UTC+01:00) Central European Time, Western European Summer Time
Languages in which this notice is officially available: German
Notice publication number: 79531-2025
OJ S issue number: 25/2025
Publication date: 05/02/2025