21.Selection criteria
The following selection criteria will be applied to candidates. In the case of applications submitted by a consortium, these selection criteria will be applied to the consortium as a whole, unless specified otherwise. The selection criteria will not be applied to economic operator and single-member companies when they are sub-contractors.
1) Economic and financial capacity of candidate (based on item 3 of the application form). In case of applicant being a public body, equivalent information should be provided.
economic operator:
(a) the annual turnover (if the candidate is an individual company) or the average annual turnover (if the candidate is a consortium) of the candidate must exceed 2 times the maximum budget of the TA operation for each of the last 3 years (2016, 2017 and 2018) for which accounts have been closed.
Note to candidates: In the application form, please make sure to include the actual year for which the data is provided.
2) Professional capacity of candidate (based on items 4 and 5 of the application form)
(a) the number of the permanent staff of the candidate (individual company or consortium overall) currently working in fields related to this contract (as they are described in item 7 – “Contract Description” above), must be at least 20 for each of the five (5) sectors (energy, environment, social, transport and digital economy) for the last 3 years (2016, 2017 and 2018), (100 total/year).
Note to candidates: In the application form, please make sure to include the actual year for which the data is provided;
(b) For each of the last 3 years (2016, 2017 and 2018), at least 40 % of the overall number of staff of the candidate (individual company or consortium overall) is permanent.
Note to candidates: In the application form, please make sure to include the actual year for which the data is provided.
3) technical capacity of candidate (based on Items 5 and 6 of the application form) legal persons:
(a) the candidate (individual company or consortium altogether) has successfully implemented, completed and final payment made during the last five (5) years at least one (1) project, in all 5 sectors: energy, environment (predominantly water and sanitation), social infrastructure (e.g. education, health, culture, penitentiary, refugee centres, justice, etc.), transport and digital economy (broadband connectivity, digital solutions across industries and public administrations, e-governance, mobile banking, etc.) of a minimum value of 800 000 EUR equivalent each, with activities on pre-feasibility and feasibility studies, design, technical assistance in tendering procedures, supervision of works, etc. at national and/or regional level were regional level should be understood to be an area of coverage of the services provided which extends over to at least 2 countries and should demonstrate that the candidate had a participation of minimum 60 % in each of the project(s) brought as reference (Projects presented as references must consist of a single contract (and addenda), have started in or after January 2014 and have been completed and final payment made by the client at any time up to the deadline of submission of applications as indicated under item 23 below); and b) The candidate (individual company or consortium altogether) has successfully implemented and completed, during the last five (5) years, 3 projects of technical assistance for enhancing promoters and/or final beneficiaries capacity. Projects presented as references must consist of a single contract (and addenda), have started in or after January 2014 and been completed and final payment made by the client at any time during the period of implementation up to the deadline of submission of applications (as indicated under Item 23 below) in IPA region/country level of a minimum value of 700 000 EUR equivalent and should demonstrate that it had a participation of minimum 60 % in each of the project(s) brought as reference.
Note to candidates: Each project presented as references will only be considered for single criteria (3 (a) or 3 (b)) and for a single sector. Technical criteria. Each project presented as references in digital economy should not be an IT system/sub-project of a project limited to one of the other 4 sectors (environment, energy, social and transport). Projects presented as references must have started in or after January 2014 and been successfully completed and final payment made by the client at any time during the period of implementation up to the deadline of submission of applications as indicated under Item 23 below. Its commencement date, completion, the amount of the project reference and the candidate’s contribution must be clearly identified and proven through adequate documentary evidence (such as certificates from the beneficiary). Where the assignments referenced have been implemented by consortia comprising 2 or more of the members now associated as a consortium for this tender procedure, their individual percentages shall be cumulated, so that the application is assessed on the basis of the candidate consortium as a whole. Note that reliance on the experience of another entity (natural or legal person) for the purposes of complying with the requirements of this selection criterion may not be considered appropriate by the Contracting Authority, regardless of the relationship the candidate has with that third party legal entity. In this regard, it is recommended that you include only those assignments for which you have been legally contracted by the client (as individual contractor or as member of a consortium).
Previous experience which caused breach of contract and termination by a Contracting Authority shall not be used as reference.
With regard to criteria relating to economic and financial standing and to criteria relating to technical and professional ability, an economic operator could, where appropriate and for a particular contract, rely on the capacities of other entities, regardless of the legal nature of the links which it has with them.
If the tenderer relies on the capacities of other entities, it must, in that case, prove to the Contracting Authority that it will have at its disposal the resources necessary for performance of the contract, for example by producing a commitment (refer to the letter of undertaking template) on the part of those entities to place those resources at its disposal. Such entities, for instance the parent company of the economic operator, must respect the same rules of eligibility — notably that of nationality – and must fulfil the same relevant selection criteria as the economic operator. The Contracting Authority shall verify whether there are grounds for exclusion. The Contracting Authority shall require that the economic operator replaces an entity which does not meet a relevant selection criterion, or in respect of which there are compulsory grounds for exclusion. The Contracting Authority may require that the economic operator substitutes an entity in respect of which there are non-compulsory grounds for exclusion. With regard to educational and professional criteria, an economic operator may only rely on the capacities of other entities where the latter will perform the services for which these capacities are required. With regard to economic and financial criteria, the entities upon whose capacity the tenderer relies become jointly liable for the execution of the contract.
Please do not submit referenced projects that are not strictly compliant with the above criteria.
If more than 8 eligible candidates meet the above selection criteria, the relative strengths and weaknesses of the applications of these candidates must be reexamined to identify the 8 best applications for the tender procedure. The only factors which will be taken into consideration during this re-examination are, in order of precedence:
1) The number of projects brought as references which comply with the requirements of the reexamination criterion 3(a);
2) The number of projects brought as references which comply with the requirements of the reexamination criterion 1 above and implemented at regional level;
3) The number of projects brought as references which comply with the requirements of criterion 3 (b);
5) In case of competition between 2 or more candidates having the same number of compliant references as per the factors for re-examination 1, 2 and 3 above, the sum of projects amounts (Fees) of references that comply with the requirements of criterion 3(a) and 3(b).